Forensic Medicine · Injury description trainer

How to Describe an Injury

The description assembles itself in front of you as you record each finding, and everything you have not recorded stays visible in it as a coloured blank — which is exactly how it will look to the lawyer cross-examining you. A trainer, not a proforma, because a proforma hides the omission.

Hurt and grievous hurt per BNS, 2023 (in force 1 July 2024) · Findings drawn from the standard texts cited under References on the Tables tab · A teaching aid — the opinion belongs to the doctor who signs it

Reference

The rules this trainer applies

Everything below is what the trainer checks your description against. It is set out here in full so it can be read, printed or searched without working through the exercise, and so that a reader without JavaScript is not left with a blank page.

What every injury description must carry

An injury description records what was seen. The nature of the injury, its age, the kind of weapon and the direction of the force are opinions, worked out afterwards from the description. Keeping the two apart is what makes a certificate survive cross-examination.

ItemWhat it meansWhy it decides cases
SiteWhich part of the body, and which side. The patient's left and right, never yours.Without a site a description matches nothing: not the weapon, not the account, not the film. Left for right is the error that undoes certificates most often, usually because the doctor wrote what was in front of them rather than what was on the patient.
Distance from landmarksHow far the injury lies from two hard, unmoving landmarks: a bone you can feel, or the midline. Fix one end of the injury, not its middle.Skin moves. Bone doesn't. "On the arm" means nothing eighteen months later when the case is finally heard. Two measurements from fixed points let a second doctor, or the court, find the same square centimetre of skin.
SizeLength by breadth in centimetres, measured against a scale, with depth added where the wound goes inwards.The item most often missing from an Indian casualty register, and the one that links a wound to a weapon. "A small cut" is not a measurement. Ask a lawyer how small.
ShapeThe outline the injury makes on the skin. Stellate and crescentic are accepted terms; star-shaped and half-moon shaped say the same thing to a court.In most injuries shape is weapon evidence. It carries the weapon alongside the margins and the angles, never on its own.
OrientationVertical, horizontal or oblique.One plain word anyone can picture, and the first thing that has to match the alleged mechanism. It costs nothing and it is missing from most casualty entries.
MarginsWhat the borders look like: clean-cut, or torn and bruised. Turned outwards, turned inwards.Margins separate an incised wound from a laceration, which is to say a knife from a lathi. Write turned outwards rather than everted; the meaning is identical and one of them survives being read aloud in court.
DepthNamed by the layer the wound reaches: skin deep, fat deep, muscle deep, bone deep, or a breach of the pleural or peritoneal cavity.A figure would mean probing, and probing can dislodge a clot and restart the bleeding. Naming the layer carries the same information and is something you saw rather than estimated.
ColourThe colour in front of you on the day you are looking at it.Colour is the foundation of the age opinion, so what belongs here is the observation rather than the conclusion you expect to draw from it. The conclusion comes later, and it holds up better for resting on something you actually saw.
Surrounding skinWhat the skin around the injury shows.The hardest questions get answered here: firing range, patterned bruising, vital reaction. All of it lives in the skin around the injury rather than in the injury itself.
Underlying structuresWhether the nerves, the major vessels or the bone beneath have been damaged.Damage to a nerve or a major vessel is found only by testing, and it is missed when the wound itself takes all the attention.
InvestigationsWhat you advised, and whether the report has come back.A report that has not arrived is a different thing from a test nobody asked for. Recording what you advised turns a bare "opinion reserved" into a defensible one.

Two opinions that are not yours to give. You may name the class of weapon, never the weapon. "Caused by a khukri" is an opinion nothing in the wound supports; "caused by a heavy sharp-edged weapon" is one you can defend all afternoon.

Manner of injury is for the investigating officer and the court. Homicidal, suicidal and accidental have no place in a hurt certificate.

Hurt and grievous hurt under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023

In force since 1 July 2024, replacing the corresponding provisions of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. Hurt is defined at section 114: bodily pain, disease or infirmity. Voluntarily causing hurt is section 115. Grievous hurt is section 116, which lists eight kinds of hurt and no others. Voluntarily causing grievous hurt is section 117.

The doctor's job is not to name the offence. It is to say whether the injury falls within one of the eight clauses, and to say so on a stated ground. Where the ground is not yet available, the honest answer is that the opinion is reserved, with the reason and the review date written down.

ClauseThe statutory kind of hurtIn plain wordsAnswerable
FirstEmasculationDepriving a man of his masculine vigour.today
SecondPermanent privation of the sight of either eyePermanence is the operative word, not injury to the eye.on review
ThirdPermanent privation of the hearing of either earNeeds audiometry and time before it can be answered.on review
FourthPrivation of any member or jointLoss of a limb, a digit or a joint.today
FifthDestruction or permanent impairing of the powers of any member or jointThe part is still there but no longer works.on review
SixthPermanent disfiguration of the head or faceAssessed after healing, and only on the head or face.on review
SeventhFracture or dislocation of a bone or toothThe commonest ground in practice. Needs imaging.on review
EighthAny hurt which endangers life, or which causes the sufferer to be during the space of fifteen days in severe bodily pain, or unable to follow his ordinary pursuitsTwo limbs. Danger to life can be answered today; fifteen days cannot.both

The thirteen findings that decide it

These are the findings the trainer looks for in your description. Each one points at a clause, and each one is either answerable on the day or has to wait. Where a finding is marked "on review", the certificate should say what is being waited for and when the patient is to be seen again.

FindingClauseWhen
The injury endangers life. A penetrating wound of the chest or abdomen, a major vessel, bleeding inside the skull, or the airway threatened. The list is open, not closed: what matters is whether this injury put life at risk.Eighthtoday
Fracture or dislocation confirmed on imaging.Seventhtoday
Fracture clinically suspected, X-ray awaited.Seventhradiological report
A tooth fractured or knocked out.Seventhtoday
Loss of a member or joint: amputation or traumatic avulsion.Fourthtoday
Emasculation.Firsttoday
The eye destroyed or removed, or vision permanently lost.Secondtoday
The eye injured with impaired vision, permanence not yet assessable.Secondophthalmology, 6 weeks
Hearing impaired after injury to the ear.ThirdENT and audiometry, 6 weeks
A member or joint injured with impaired power, permanence not yet assessable.Fifthafter healing, 6 weeks
Permanent disfiguration of the head or face already established.Sixthtoday
An injury on the head or face likely to leave a permanent mark.Sixthonce healed, 6 weeks
Severe bodily pain, or unable to follow ordinary pursuits, for fifteen days.Eighthfifteen days

Where a burn or a corrosive is concerned, the routes to grievous are narrower. A corrosive does not fracture bone or knock out teeth; it reaches grievous through the eye, the face, a contracture across a joint, danger to life, and the fifteen-day limb. A burn is the same, reaching grievous through the area involved, the face, a contracture, the eye and the fifteen days, and not through fractures or avulsions. On area alone, danger to life is reached at forty per cent or more.

An abrasion of any size will not fracture, avulse or blind. What it can do is disfigure the face and keep someone off work. A bite can avulse tissue and disfigure a face; it will not fracture bone. A ligature mark points at danger to life, at disfiguration, and at hearing where the vessels of the neck were involved.

How old is the injury

Age is given as a range, never as a single figure, and the range must rest on something recorded in the description. What follows is the correspondence between what is seen and what may be said. Where the appearances are mixed, the oldest feature governs.

Abrasion, by the state of the scab

What is seenAge
Reddish, oozing serum and a little bloodfresh
A reddish scab, the exudate having driedabout 12 to 24 hours
A reddish-brown scab, less tender and adhering to the areaabout 2 to 3 days
A dark brown scababout 4 to 5 days
A brownish-black scab, beginning to fall away at the marginsabout 5 to 7 days
The scab shrunken and fallen off, leaving a depigmented areaabout 7 to 10 days
The depigmented area gradually regaining its colourweeks

Contusion, by colour

What is seenAge
Reddishfresh
Bluishwithin a few hours
Bluish-purpleabout the 2nd day
Bluish-blackabout the 3rd to 4th day
Brownishabout the 4th to 5th day
Greenishabout the 5th to 7th day
Yellowabout the 7th to 10th day
More than one colour at once, purple towards the centre and yellow at the edgesseveral days at least; a large bruise holds all its colours together as it clears
Back to normal skin colourabout 2 weeks

Colour dating carries one firm rule and a great deal of caution. Yellow indicates a bruise more than about eighteen hours old; its absence indicates nothing at all. The rest is a guide, not a clock.

Laceration and incised wound, by the state of healing

What is seenAge
Bleeding, or a fresh soft clot, the margins swollen, red and tenderfresh
The margins swollen and red, the clot and lymph dried upabout 12 to 24 hours
A thin continuous layer of epithelium beneath the scababout 24 to 48 hours
Granulation tissue invading the woundabout 2 to 3 days
Granulation tissue filling the wound, new vessels at their peakabout 4 to 5 days
A soft reddish scar, the epidermis back to its normal thicknessabout a week
Healed, with a mature scar formedmore than 2 weeks

Burn, by the state of healing

What is seenAge
Redness only, no blisters yetimmediate; redness appears at once, blistering following in about 2 to 3 hours
Blistering, with the exudate still moistabout 2 to 12 hours
The exudate dryingabout 12 to 24 hours
A dry brown crust formed, the red zone fadingabout 48 to 72 hours; the red inflammatory zone goes at 36 to 72
Pus formedat least 36 hours, and usually 2 to 3 days
Superficial slough separatingabout the 4th to 6th day
Deeper slough separatingabout 2 weeks
Granulation tissue covering the areabeyond about 2 weeks
Healed, with a scar formedseveral weeks to months, depending on depth, extent and any suppuration

Bite mark, by the state of healing

What is seenAge
Indented tooth marks, reddishfresh
Bruising developing within the marksabout 12 to 24 hours
Bruise darkening, the indentations fadingabout 2 to 4 days
Bruise fading, the pattern largely lostabout 1 week

A bite mark is not a kind of injury in itself. The teeth produce abrasions, contusions or lacerations, and those are what the description records. Swab for saliva and photograph with a scale beside the mark before anything is cleaned. The doctor does not name who bit the person.

The RIGHT score for head injury

A scoring system for the medico-legal classification of head injury, published by Gupta and colleagues in Neurology India in 2023. Three components are added together.

ComponentFindingPoints
X — motor responseM6, obeys commands0
M5, localises to pain1
M4 or below: withdrawal, flexion, extension or none4
Y — imagingCT normal, no finding of acute trauma0
CT shows acute traumatic findings1
Z — managementConservative medical management only: analgesics, antibiotics, antacids, scalp suturing0
Neurosurgical medical management, such as cerebral decongestants1
Intubation or elective ventilation3
Surgery indicated, whether or not it was performed4

A total of 0 is simple. 1 to 3 is grievous. 4 and above is dangerous. The score is an aid to consistency between doctors, not a substitute for the clauses of section 116.

Plain words instead of medical jargon

The report will be read by judges, lawyers and police officers. Where a plain word says the same thing, use it. The technical term can stay alongside in brackets where it earns its place.

Instead ofWriteInstead ofWrite
anteriorfrontecchymosisbruise
posteriorbackerythemaredness
medialinner sideoedemaswelling
lateralouter sidehaematomaa collection of blood
ventralfront ofcrepitusa grating felt on touch
dorsalback ofexudateoozing fluid
superiorupper, or aboveepistaxisbleeding from the nose
inferiorlower, or belowabradedgrazed
proximalnearer the trunkevertedturned outwards
distalfurther from the trunkinvertedturned inwards
cephaladtowards the headexcoriationa scrape
caudaltowards the feetindurationhardness felt on touch

The defects this trainer is built to catch

  1. "Multiple injuries present over the body." Each injury is a separate injury with its own number, site, size and age. This phrase describes nothing and cannot be matched to a weapon or to an account.
  2. "A small cut." Small is not a measurement. Size in centimetres, length by breadth, is the single most commonly omitted essential.
  3. "On the head." No side, no region, no distance from a fixed landmark. Months later nobody can say where this was.
  4. "On the arm." Which arm? Left and right must be the patient's, and must be stated.
  5. "Caused by a knife." You may name the class of weapon, never the weapon. A sharp-edged weapon is defensible; a knife is not.
  6. "Simple in nature", written before the X-ray. Given without a stated ground, and given before the imaging. Where a fracture is possible, the honest answer is that the opinion is reserved.
  7. "Appears to be homicidal." Manner is never for the doctor in a hurt certificate.
  8. An incised wound with irregular margins. If the margins are irregular and bruised, it is a laceration, whatever it was called at the top of the entry.

References

Hurt and grievous hurt per the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, in force 1 July 2024 · A teaching aid — the opinion belongs to the doctor who signs it
Dr Harvinder Singh Chhabra · [email protected] · Licensed CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 · Forensic Medicine Workbench